HOME / Insights

Where the ATO sits in a deed, and how to work with it

Director and advisor reviewing a deed of company arrangement proposal involving the ATO

Where the ATO sits in a deed, and how to work with it

In most small and mid-market administrations the Australian Taxation Office is the single largest creditor by value, which means it frequently decides the vote. Small business collectable debt has reached $35.9 billion and has grown 118% since 2018-19. Directors who treat the ATO as a counterparty rather than an obstacle get better proposals in front of creditors, and get them there faster.

There is a particular tone that creeps into conversations about the ATO in a distressed business. It is somewhere between resentment and fatalism, and it is understandable. It is also the single least useful posture a director can bring into a deed proposal.

In a deed, the ATO is a creditor. It votes like a creditor, it weighs the proposal like a creditor, and where it holds the majority of the debt by value it can decide the outcome like a creditor. The work is to give it a reason to vote yes.

The context every director should have

The environment has changed, and it has changed in a direction that matters for anyone contemplating a restructure.

According to the Australian National Audit Office's review of the ATO's management of small business collectable debt, small business collectable debt has reached $35.9 billion, and it grew 118% between 2018-19 and 2024-25. The small business collectable debt ratio, being small business collectable debt measured against net small business tax collections, sat at 34.2%, well outside the ATO's whole of agency collectable debt ratio target of around 6%.

Those two percentages are measured on different bases and should not be read as a single gap. The ANAO's actual finding was blunter: the ATO had no internal targets for reducing small business debt volumes at all, and the ANAO recommended it set them.

Read together, the direction is still obvious. Recovery pressure on small business debt is increasing rather than easing. Payment plans that were routinely granted a few years ago are not being granted on the same terms. Directors who assume the position they had in 2021 is the position they have now are working from an old map.

The practical consequence for a deed is twofold. The ATO is likely to be your largest creditor, and it is under pressure to recover rather than to wait.

What the ATO weighs

Describing the ATO's internal decision making with any precision would be presumptuous, and we do not intend to. What can be said, from the deeds we have taken through creditor approval and from the ATO's own published material about how it approaches recovery, is that three things come up consistently.

  1. Whether the deed returns more than liquidation. This is the comparison every creditor makes, and it is the comparison the administrator's report is built around. It is also where a deed usually wins on the numbers administrators themselves put to creditors. In ASIC's Report 836 population, where a voluntary administration ended in creditors' voluntary liquidation instead, administrators' own high estimate was that around a quarter of those liquidations might pay any dividend at all, and the median estimate was nil. Those are estimates of the counterfactual recorded at the second meeting, not observed liquidation outcomes. That is a strong argument, but it only works if the proposal's numbers are credible. A deed fund that depends on a forecast the business has never hit is not a better return. It is a hope.
  2. Lodgement and payment history. This is where most proposals are quietly won or lost, and it is almost entirely within the company's control. A company with a long history of lodging late, or of entering payment arrangements and defaulting on them, is asking a creditor to believe a forecast from a business that has not previously met its commitments. A company that has lodged consistently, even where it could not pay, is making a materially different request. If lodgements are outstanding, bring them up to date before the proposal is put. It improves the proposal, and separately it is the single act that most affects a director's personal exposure under the director penalty regime.
  3. Whether future obligations will actually be met. A deed that compromises historical debt and then generates a new one within six months is worse than useless. Expect scrutiny of the post-deed operating model: whether the business can pay its ongoing PAYG withholding, superannuation and GST out of trading, and whether the restructure has actually removed the cause of the arrears or merely deferred them. A proposal that addresses this directly, with the forward compliance position modelled and stated, is doing something most proposals do not.

What the alternative path looks like

It is worth being clear about what happens if the conversation does not happen. The ATO's recovery options do not wait for a company to decide it is ready. Garnishee notices redirect money before it reaches the business. Director penalty notices move the liability to a person. A winding up application ends the conversation entirely.

ASIC's data says something useful about that last one. Where there were winding up proceedings within 90 days before the appointment, the appointment produced a deed around 26% of the time. Where no application had been made, 45%. ASIC reports the association without explaining it, and a company facing a wind up application is further into its distress either way. But the size of the gap is hard to ignore, and it points in one direction: the options are wider before an application is filed than after.

That is a different 26% from the one earlier in this article, which is a good illustration of why every figure from Report 836 needs its population attached to it.

Know what the debt is actually made of

A single figure on an integrated client account statement is not a position. Before any proposal is modelled, break the balance into its components, because they do not behave the same way.

  • Primary tax. Income tax, net GST and PAYG withholding amounts that were always the company's to pay.
  • General interest charge. Interest that has accrued on the unpaid amounts, and which on a long-running arrears position can be a substantial share of the balance.
  • Administrative penalties. Failure to lodge, shortfall and related penalties.
  • Superannuation guarantee charge. Which behaves differently again, carries its own components, and interacts directly with the director penalty regime.

The split matters for three reasons. It changes the credibility of the proposal, because a balance dominated by interest tells a different story from one dominated by unremitted withholding. It changes the director's personal exposure, because only some components sit inside the director penalty regime. And it bears on the tax outcome of the compromise, because the debt forgiveness rules in Division 245 only reach a commercial debt, and whether a compromised tax liability answers that description is an open question that turns partly on the deductibility of general interest charge in the relevant period.

Get the statement, break it down, and take advice on the components before deciding what to offer.

Sequencing: engage before the proposal is finalised

The most common mistake we see is a proposal that is fully drafted, costed and lodged, and only then put in front of the largest creditor in the room. If the ATO has an issue with it, everything downstream has to be redone, and the fifteen business day execution clock is unforgiving of rework.

A better order:

  1. Get the lodgements current. Everything else is harder without this.
  2. Establish the actual position: primary tax, general interest charge, penalties, and which components sit where.
  3. Model the liquidation comparison honestly, including what a liquidator would realistically recover and when.
  4. Open the conversation early, with a clear picture of the funding source rather than an intention to find one.
  5. Address forward compliance explicitly in the proposal, not in a covering letter.
  6. Deal with any director penalty position as a term of the proposal rather than as an afterthought.

A closing thought on posture

The ATO is not sentimental, and it is not looking for a reason to say no. It is a creditor with an obligation to recover, deciding between a compromise it can evaluate and an outcome that, on the published data, usually returns nothing.

Given a credible proposal from a company that has been straight with it, that is not a difficult choice. The work is in making the proposal credible, and most of that work happens before anyone drafts a document.

Speak with our deed advocacy team

We act as deed advocates for directors, shareholders and investors, and a large part of that work is preparing the proposal that the largest creditor in the room will actually support. If the ATO is your major creditor and a proposal is being contemplated, the sequencing conversation is worth having early.

General information only. This is not tax, legal or insolvency advice and does not take your circumstances into account. Descriptions of how the ATO approaches proposals are general observations from published material and practice, not statements of ATO policy. Obtain advice specific to your circumstances before acting.

Sources:  Australian National Audit Office performance audit, Australian Taxation Office management of small business collectable debt, 2026; ASIC Report 836, Review of voluntary administration and deed of company arrangement process 2021 to 2025, published 7 July 2026; Division 269 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953

Speak to the Olvera Expert

Picture of Damien Hodgkinson

Damien Hodgkinson

Principal
Damien develops strategic solutions for groups dealing in crisis management and/or distress investment.

Table of Contents

Your Turnaround Starts Here

With decades of experience in restructuring and advisory, Olvera Advisors helps businesses unlock new possibilities. Take the first step toward a stronger tomorrow.

Related Articles

Read our latest articles and insights on the world of business insolvency in Australia.

Insights
What directors need to know before choosing a voluntary administrator, including conflict rules, the independence declaration, and how creditors can replace that choice within eight ...
Insights
If David Jones shrinks to 15 stores, who absorbs the fallout? We model the impact on landlords, staff, suppliers and distribution in a reset scenario. ...
Insights
Construction insolvencies peak over the Christmas close-down. This article explains why builders fail at year end and what directors should do if theirs is at ...