HOME / Insights

Choosing the right Administrator - experience and independence

Directors reviewing documents when choosing a voluntary administrator for their company

Directors choose the voluntary administrator. Creditors can replace that choice within eight business days, and a court can remove them at any time. The appointment itself cannot be revoked by the board that made it. Here is what the decided cases say about conflicts, what the independence declaration does and does not achieve, and how replacement at the first meeting actually works.

There is a line in Part 5.3A that most directors never read and every director should: the appointment of a person as administrator of a company cannot be revoked.

Not by the board that made it. Once the resolution is passed and the consent is in place, the only ways out run through the creditors or through a court. Every other decision in a voluntary administration can be revisited. This one cannot.

Directors typically spend an afternoon on it, in the worst week of the company's life, and choose on availability. It is worth more than that, and the reason is measurable.

ASIC's Report 836 reviewed every voluntary administration over four financial years. Administrators recommended approval of 95% of the deed proposals put to a vote. Creditors approved 89% of the proposals that were recommended. Of the 5% recommended against, 42% were still approved. Creditors are not a rubber stamp, but a negative recommendation from the administrator roughly halves a proposal's chances.

When choosing an administrator, directors should weigh two things: the administrator's knowledge of the industry, which shapes their decision on whether to keep trading, and their independence from you as the appointer.

Industry Experience

Not all administrators are the same. Administrators make rapid commercial decisions about whether to keep trading, how to fund operations and whether the business is viable, and they make each one knowing they can be personally liable for it.

An administrator unfamiliar with the industry will be more cautious and may misjudge the viability of the business, terminate salvageable contracts, and fail to understand and preserve key relationships, leading to further deterioration of the company.

When creditors weigh the administrator's recommendation, they will quickly judge whether the administrator understands the business's operational risks, whether the forecasts are realistic, and whether the trading decisions are commercially sound.

Independence - the test is appearance, not influence

Australian courts do not ask whether a practitioner was actually influenced. They apply the test for apprehended bias set out by the High Court in Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy: whether a fair-minded lay observer might reasonably apprehend that the decision-maker might not bring an impartial mind to the decision.

There has to be an identified matter that might lead the decision-maker away from the merits, and a stated logical connection between that matter and the feared departure. A bare assertion of interest is not sufficient.

The Full Federal Court applied Ebner to insolvency practitioners in ASIC v Franklin, in the matter of Walton Constructions, and added a qualification: practitioners have to attract work and operate commercially. Independence does not mean having no relationships. It means not having one that a reasonable observer would think could bend the outcome.

What the cases actually treat as a conflict

The referral relationship. In Franklin, the practitioners' firm had received insolvency referrals from a pre-insolvency adviser worth about $500,000 in one year, roughly 10% of the insolvency division's revenue, and about $250,000 the next. The same adviser had been involved in the company's pre-appointment transactions, so the liquidators would have had to investigate their own referrer. The Court held that a fair-minded observer might consider the firm would not wish to put income of those proportions in jeopardy, and ordered removal. There was no finding that anyone had actually done anything improper, and removal was ordered even though the Court acknowledged the considerable inconvenience and expense it would cause.

Substantial pre-appointment work. In Korda, in the matter of Ten Network Holdings, the administrators' firm had done about three months and more than $1 million of pre-appointment work. The Federal Court found a reasonable apprehension of bias, but the finding is narrower than the headline suggests. Volume of pre-appointment work alone was not enough. The Court accepted that contingency planning before an appointment is legitimate and encouraged. The problems lay elsewhere. The administrators had been appointed by, were paid by, and were in a referral relationship with a law firm they might have to investigate. They would also have to assess whether their own pre-appointment fees were voidable preferences. Rather than removing them, the Court appointed an independent special purpose liquidator to report on claims against the directors, officers and advisers, including the administrators themselves. Removal is not the only outcome available.

Having acted for the secured creditor. In Domino Hire v Pioneer Park, the practitioner had acted as investigating accountant for the company's bank, then became administrator, then liquidator. The notice of meeting said that neither he, his partner nor his staff had had prior professional dealings with the company. The Court held that, even if literally true, that statement conveyed a misleading impression, and that the appearance of a lack of independence was quite real. Both partners were removed, including the one who had done none of the earlier work, because he was in partnership with the practitioner who had.

Where the line sits, in both directions

Courts are also alert to independence complaints run for tactical reasons. In Re Biposo, the Court warned that it must take care not to become an instrument of those who seek merely for their own purposes to disrupt the due course of the liquidation.

And in ASIC v Jones in 2023, the Western Australian Court of Appeal found that about three months of pre-appointment advisory work did give rise to a conflict and a reasonable apprehension of bias. However, it declined to reduce the practitioners' remuneration, because the conflict was inadvertent, no creditor had objected, and the practitioners had not in fact been deflected from their duties.

The independence declaration, and the 2 things people get wrong

Every voluntary administrator must make a declaration of relevant relationships and a declaration of indemnities. The mechanics are tight. The declaration must be made as soon as practicable after appointment, given to as many creditors as reasonably practicable at the same time as the notice of the first meeting, tabled at that meeting, and lodged with ASIC. If it becomes out of date or an error is found, a replacement declaration must be made as soon as practicable, tabled at the next meeting and lodged again.

It must cover whether the administrator, their partners or their firm has, or has had in the past two years, a relationship with the company, an associate of the company, a former external administrator, the nominating creditor, or a person holding security over substantially the whole of the company's property. It must also give the reasons for believing that none of those relationships results in a conflict.

Mistake one: treating disclosure as a cure. It is not. In the Ten Network decision, the Federal Court adopted the words of the explanatory memorandum: including a relationship in a declaration "will in no way cure any conflict of interest or conflict of duties that may arise out of that relationship, even if creditors approve the appointment after the declaration is made". The ARITA Code says the same. Naming a problem is not solving it.

Mistake two: treating the declaration as the battleground. This one cuts the other way, and a good deal of commentary gets it backwards. No Australian court has removed a practitioner for a defective declaration standing alone. In Franklin, ASIC ran a separate ground that the declaration was deficient. That ground failed. The Court held that a bare intention to investigate a transaction of an entity does not itself constitute a relationship between those entities, and that the requirement to state a relationship does not cover the entire field of conflict of interest or duty. The removal followed from the conflict, not from the declaration.

Your creditors review the choice in eight business days

The first creditors' meeting must be held within eight business days after the administration begins, on at least five business days' notice. Its statutory purpose is to decide whether to appoint a committee of inspection. But creditors may also pass a resolution removing the administrator from office and appointing someone else.

That power has a practical precondition. A replacement must be a registered liquidator, must not be caught by the statutory disqualifications, and must have consented in writing before the meeting. In practice, they also provide their own independence declaration with the notice. The threshold is a majority of creditors in both number and value.

On a resolution to remove the external administrator, the chair may use a casting vote in favour of their own removal, but cannot use one against it.

A replacement motion has to be organised: a willing practitioner found, a signed consent and declaration obtained, and all of it circulated, inside a week. That only happens when a substantial creditor has decided your choice of administrator is not acceptable.

The clearest recent illustration is the Steller Developments litigation in the New South Wales Supreme Court in 2020. The majority creditor, owed about $101.9 million, moved a replacement resolution at the first meeting. The administrator ruled it lost on the voices against two creditors owed $1,090.90 and $495.00, declined to put it to a poll, and said he would not exercise a casting vote.

The creditor commenced proceedings. The matter was resolved by consent orders removing the administrator and appointing replacements under the court's general power over external administrations. That dispute consumed two weeks of a 20-business-day convening period.

Choose for credibility, not agreement

An independent administrator is not an obstacle to a deed. They are the reason a deed is worth anything to creditors. The recommendation that carries 89% of the vote carries it because the person making it has nothing riding on the answer.

The goal is not an administrator who will agree with you. It is one whose agreement will be believed, appointed on a basis that survives creditor scrutiny, and told early enough to test your proposal properly.

Get that right and the rest of the process is a negotiation. Get it wrong and it starts with a replacement motion.

Speak with our deed advocacy team

We act as deed advocates to directors, shareholders and incoming investors. That includes selecting the administrator on industry experience, cost, capacity and a declaration that will not become the story; negotiating the funding of the administration; preparing and negotiating the deed proposal; and taking the deed through execution and completion. If you are weeks away from an appointment, that is the right time to talk, not the week after.

General information only. It is not legal or insolvency advice and does not take your circumstances into account. Case summaries are necessarily compressed and each turned on its own facts. Obtain advice before acting.

Sources

  1. Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2000] HCA 63; (2000) 205 CLR 337
  2. ASIC v Franklin (liquidator), in the matter of Walton Constructions Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 85, on appeal from [2014] FCA 68
  3. Korda, in the matter of Ten Network Holdings Ltd (Administrators Appointed) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2017] FCA 914
  4. Domino Hire Pty Ltd v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (in liq) [1999] NSWSC 1046
  5. Advance Housing Pty Ltd (in liq) v Newcastle Classic Developments Pty Ltd (1994) 14 ACSR 230
  6. Re Biposo Pty Ltd; Condon v Rodgers (1995) 17 ACSR 730
  7. ACN 168 479 614 Pty Ltd (formerly Steller Developments Pty Ltd) (Administrator Appointed) [2020] NSWSC 29
  8. ASIC v Jones [2023] WASCA 130 and ASIC v Bettles [2023] FCA 975
  9. Part 5.3A, Corporations Act 2001, and the Insolvency Practice Schedule and Rules (Corporations)
  10. 2016 ASIC Information Sheet 84, Independence of external administrators, and Information Sheet 74
  11. ASIC Report 836, Review of voluntary administration and deed of company arrangement, July 2026

Speak to the Olvera Expert

Picture of Damien Hodgkinson

Damien Hodgkinson

Principal
Damien develops strategic solutions for groups dealing in crisis management and/or distress investment.

Table of Contents

Your Turnaround Starts Here

With decades of experience in restructuring and advisory, Olvera Advisors helps businesses unlock new possibilities. Take the first step toward a stronger tomorrow.

Related Articles

Read our latest articles and insights on the world of business insolvency in Australia.

Insights
If David Jones shrinks to 15 stores, who absorbs the fallout? We model the impact on landlords, staff, suppliers and distribution in a reset scenario. ...
Insights
Construction insolvencies peak over the Christmas close-down. This article explains why builders fail at year end and what directors should do if theirs is at ...
Insights
Gift cards are unsecured loans to retailers, not money. With David Jones and others under pressure, here is what happens to your balance if a ...