Privilege losses look sudden. They aren’t.
The Mosaic Brands directors did most things right. They took safe harbour advice early, from March 2020. They retained the lawyers themselves. And in October 2026 the Federal Court agreed the advice was privileged to them personally, not to the company.
They still lost it.
What the Court decided
In McCabe v Mosaic Brands Ltd (in liq) [2026] FCA 1569, Justice Markovic dealt with a question every board in safe harbour should care about: who owns the advice, and how easily can it be lost?
The special purpose liquidators wanted the advice for possible insolvent trading claims. The directors said it was theirs alone. Here is how it played out:
- The directors owned the privilege. Safe harbour is pursued for the company’s benefit, but the protection belongs to the directors. The law firm’s view that its engagement was with the company was not conclusive.
- A voluntary handover waived it. In December 2024 the directors gave the administrators a safe harbour timeline and memo. The request had only sought a summary. Calling the disclosure “inadvertent” in the covering email did not help, because it was made on advice and on purpose.
- The waiver travelled. It did not stop at the administrators. It reached the general purpose liquidators, the special purpose liquidators and beyond.
- Board minutes waived it separately. Recording the substance of the advice in minutes was enough on its own.
- Some things did not waive it. Sharing the advice with staff who were helping the directors was fine. Sending minutes to the auditor was not shown to be a waiver.
- One question is still open. Whether the restructuring adviser’s supporting work is privileged has not been decided.
The lesson is uncomfortable. The moment directors most want to rely on their advice, to show they qualified for safe harbour, is the moment they are most likely to lose it.
The new privilege playbook
Mosaic turns privilege from a label into a process. Here is how we now expect safe harbour engagements to run.
- Name the client properly. The engagement letter should name the directors as the client. Not “the board”, not “the group”. If the company pays, say it pays as a third party and nothing more.
- Split the work. Advice to the directors on their personal position is one retainer. Advice to the company on executing the turnaround is another. Separate letters, invoices and files.
- Bring restructuring advisers in through the lawyers. The Deloitte question is unresolved. Until it is, have the lawyers engage the restructuring adviser so the work is done to enable legal advice.
- Run a separate safe harbour pack. The chair circulates it to directors only, marked privileged. Keep it out of the general board papers.
- Discuss it in camera and minute almost nothing. The minutes should say the advice was received and considered, and record the decision. The substance stays out of the minute book.
- Tell staff why you are asking. When the team gathers information for the advisers, make clear it is confidential and for legal advice to the directors.
- Get advice before you answer an administrator. A request for a summary is not an order to hand over the advice. Respond to what is actually asked, not more.
- Remember privilege is joint. Every director who took the advice, including those who have since retired, should be consulted before anyone waives it.
None of this is heavy. Most of it is ten minutes of discipline at the right moment.
Your deed of access and indemnity was written before Mosaic
Most standard directors’ deeds share three gaps. We found all three in a deed we reviewed this week.
- They don’t clearly pay for safe harbour advice. The usual indemnity covers legal costs for an actual or threatened claim. Safe harbour advice is taken before anyone is threatening anything.
- They can be used to demand the advice. Clauses requiring directors to give the company or insurers “all documents” don’t distinguish privileged safe harbour material.
- They say nothing about who owns the privilege. That leaves the company’s payment of the bills as the loudest evidence of who the client was.
The fix is a dedicated safe harbour clause to be prepared by your solicitors. At a minimum it should:
- Let the director retain advisers in their own name and require the company to pay, as third-party payer only, with no right to see the advice or waive privilege.
- Cover advice before any claim exists, plus the cost of advice on responding to administrators, liquidators, notices and examinations.
- Allow payment in advance into the adviser’s trust account. Once the company is insolvent, an indemnity is just an unsecured claim.
- Keep invoices generic. Enough to check the fees are reasonable, nothing that reveals the advice.
- Record that the privilege is the director’s, held jointly with co-directors, and that the company holds any copies in confidence.
- Build in the board process: separate packs, in camera discussion and bare minutes.
- Stop production without consent or a court order, with notice to the director so privilege can be asserted.
- Carve safe harbour material out of the document-return, co-operation and insurer-assistance clauses.
- Make it survive resignation, external administration and termination, and offer matching deeds to every director.
A small caveat, a deed cannot override a liquidator’s statutory powers or a court’s view of who the client was. It is supporting evidence. The engagement letters and the board’s conduct still do the heavy lifting.
The takeaway
Safe harbour was designed to give directors the confidence to fight for a better outcome. Mosaic shows that the confidence depends on paperwork most boards never look at.
The advice itself is rarely the problem. How it is commissioned, circulated, minuted and handed over is.
If you sit on a board that is in, or heading towards, safe harbour, ask three questions this week:
- Who is named as the client in our engagement letters?
- What do our last six months of minutes actually say?
- Does our deed of access and indemnity pay for this advice, and protect it?
If any answer makes you pause, talk to your lawyers and to us. Turning uncertainty into your advantage starts with not handing it away.
This article is general commentary, not legal advice. Directors should get specific legal advice on privilege and their own deeds.