Skip to content

Olvera Advisors are the administrators of Mansa and Sons PTY LTD   Learn more

  • Regions
    • Australia
    • Cook islands
    • Fiji
    • Indonesia
    • Kiribati
    • Marshall Islands
    • Micronesia
    • Nauru
    • New Zealand
    • Pacific
    • Palau
    • Papua New Guinea
    • Samoa
    • Solomon Islands
    • Timor Leste
    • Tonga
    • Tuvalu
    • Vanuatu
  • Regions
    • Australia
    • Cook islands
    • Fiji
    • Indonesia
    • Kiribati
    • Marshall Islands
    • Micronesia
    • Nauru
    • New Zealand
    • Pacific
    • Palau
    • Papua New Guinea
    • Samoa
    • Solomon Islands
    • Timor Leste
    • Tonga
    • Tuvalu
    • Vanuatu
Olvera Logo Black
  • Services

    Our Services

    Restructuring & Turnaround
    Risk Management
    Forensics
    CFO Advisory
    Insolvency

    Restructuring & Turnaround

    What sets us apart in company turnaround and restructuring advisory is our comprehensive and client-focused approach. We don’t just see numbers; we see the people and potential behind those numbers.
    See Restructuring & Turnaround
    Safe Harbour
    One of the key hurdles hindering a director’s willingness to take on financial risk has been their potential personal exposure for damages as a result of insolvent trading.
    See More...
    Corporate Streamlining

    As companies grow through acquisition so to does their corporate structure. Over time those structures become more complex, while entities may also become redundant as businesses or projects end.

    See More...
    Exit Planning & Integration

    Exit planning is one of the most important processes an owner can undertake, and at Olvera Advisors, we specialize in providing comprehensive and effective exit planning services.

    See More...
    Chief Restructuring Officer

    Olvera believes that an effective CRO creates a reset for an organisation, they inspire and embed the change that needs to happen for an organisation to succeed. 

    See More...

    Risk Management

    In today’s fast-pacеd and unprеdictablе еconomic landscapе, еffеctivе risk managеmеnt is not just a choicе; it’s a vital componеnt of businеss succеss.
    See Risk Management
    Counterparty Financial Assessment
    All contracts require a company to assume some level of contractual risk. Understanding who you are doing business with and their financial capacity to complete the contract helps to mitigate but not eliminate that risk, it also helps contracting parties in their negotiation positions and makes the outcomes clear before they enter into contract.
    See More...
    Asset Protection Risk Management

    Every day, each decision we make changes our risk. As the risk alters both positively and negatively, so do our perception of the decisions we have made.

    See More...
    Regulatory Compliance
    Compliance and regulatory requirements are an inescapable part of conducting any business. It is therefore necessary to build compliance frameworks that are efficient, cost-effective, and can be embedded into operational processes to avoid duplication of effort.
    See More...
    Payroll Consulting & Award Compliance
    At Olvera Advisors, we specialize in providing comprehensive payroll compliance and consulting services. Our team of experts is dedicated to helping businesses navigate the complexities of payroll management, ensuring compliance with Australian laws and regulations, and optimizing payroll processes for efficiency and accuracy.
    See More...
    Financial Crime
    As businesses expand their global footprint, the risk of financial crime increases. Regulatory bodies, both locally and internationally, are intensifying their focus on various forms of crime – financial, social, human – that can occur within a business, due to its domestic and global operations, or through its connections
    See More...
    Governance
    Robust, scalable, and sustainable governance frameworks are essential for businesses to make the right decisions at the right time. Effective governance comprises interconnected activities, including structures such as Boards, Committees, and Executive Teams.
    See More...

    Forensics

    In the ever-evolving world of finance and accounting, having an experienced partner like Olvera Advisors is invaluable. Our team of expert forensic accountants can help simplify complex financial scenarios.
    See Forensics
    Forensic Accounting
    When someone is needed to investigate what has happened to review, interview and challenge collate and analyse Olvera has the people and resources to get you the answer you need.
    See More...
    Dispute Advisory
    Navigate complex financial disputes with Olvera Advisors’ Dispute Advisory services. Expert guidance at all stages of litigation, ensuring value preservation.
    See More...
    Investigations
    Uncover misconduct with Olvera Advisors’ Investigations services. Licensed forensic investigators delivering high-quality results across jurisdictions.
    See More...
    Expert Witness & IER’s
    Olvera Advisors provides comprehensive Independent Expert Reports and Expert Witness services for fair and compliant corporate transactions.
    See More...
    Anti Money Laundering
    Secure your business with Olvera Advisors’ Anti Money Laundering services. Comprehensive solutions to minimize risks from criminal activities.
    See More...

    CFO Advisory

    Olvera Advisers’ suite of CFO Advisory services is designed to assist Boards and Senior Management in better managing and understanding the financial performance of their business to make more informed and sustainable business decisions.
    See CFO Advisory
    Financial Analysis

    Our Financial Analysis programme helps management build the financial business case for a new capital investment including budgets and then establishes the appropriate financial performance KPI for the Board and Management to monitor and assess the financial return. 

    See More...
    Interim CFO
    From maternity leave to bad leavers change happens, Olvera has a roster of experienced CFOs across industries that we can parachute into your business to provide temporary role cover or to manage a specific situation or programme so that your business remains on financial track.
    See More...
    Management Support

    Our external accounting services help you improve and better understand your financial performance from basic bookkeeping to complex data analysis supporting you making better management decisions. Knowing where you are at all times allows you to set the direction you are going.

    See More...
    Sustainability

    The world we live in is changing, and Australia has been behind the pack when it comes to sustainability. The Australian government’s Climate Act 2022 came into effect on 14 September 2022.

    See More...
    Working Capital Optimisation

    Even in times of low interest rates, cash is still king, especially in situations where external funding is unavailable or cash on balance sheet is an important issue for lending and covenant management.

    See More...

    Insolvency

    Our experienced team simplifies the insolvency process, ensuring clarity and empowering you to make informed decisions, even in the most challenging financial situations.
    See Insolvency
    Voluntary Administration & DOCA

    Evaluating businesses, projects, budgets, and business cases to determine their financial performance is just part of the programme of Financial Analysis services that you need to support your business.

    See More...
    Asset Tracing Investigations
    At Olvera Advisors, we specialize in asset tracing investigations. Our team of seasoned professionals utilizes advanced techniques to uncover hidden or obscured assets. Whether you’re dealing with a complex divorce, a corporate dispute, or a fraud case, our asset tracing services can provide the clarity you need.
    See More...
    Safe Harbour Advisory

    One of the key hurdles hindering a director’s willingness to take on financial risk has been their potential personal exposure for damages as a result of insolvent trading.

    See More...
    Creditor Advisory Services
    At Olvera Advisors, we offer top-tier creditor advisory services, providing our clients with strategic and actionable advice to navigate complex financial landscapes. Our team of experts is dedicated to maximising creditor recoveries and enhancing credit risk scores.
    See More...
    Deed Advocacy
    Olvera represents investors, fund providers and management in taking strategic advantage of changing economic environments to ensure that they have the ability to maximise or minimise the impact of uncertain change on their businesses.
    See More...
    Facebook Instagram Linkedin
  • Experience

    Our Experience

    Consumer Services
    Technology & Communication
    Hospitality & Media
    Construction & Property
    Energy & Resources
    Financial Services
    Transport & Manufacturing
    Health & Education

    Consumer Services

    Australia’s relative smaller population means the retail market is dominated by a number of large players. This has also resulted in a lack of diversity of brands products and services.
    See Consumer Services
    Key Insight
    Insolvency & Restructuring in the Consumer Services Industry in 2024

    Insolvency & Restructuring in the Consumer Services Industry in 2024

    The consumer services industry is a quintessential pillar of the Australian economy, embodying a vast swath of sectors from retail and hospitality to tourism,
    Read More...
    Recent News
    Ginger Smart 1

    Celebrating olvera's achievements over the past 2 years

    Through standing by our values, the hard work of our people and the continuous support of our clients, partners, referrers, and industry friends,
    Read More...
    Case Study

    Ellery

    Ellery is a luxury Australian fashion brand with design offices in Paris and Milan and production facilities in Sydney.

    Less than 5% of global sales were generated in Australia through a local shopfront and wholesale clients.
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Technology & Communication

    The asset values for e-commerce and technology start-ups have fallen significantly and a number of capital raising have resulted in what are “down rounds” highly dilutive capital raisings.

    See Technology & Communication
    Key Insight
    5 things 1

    5 things a business can do during a crisis

    While many businesses find themselves in an economic crisis amid the COVID-19 epidemic, it is crucial to be proactive and act as soon as possible.
    Read More...
    Recent News
    Kate Barnet named chair

    Kate Barnet named chair of ARITA’S Balance Taskforce Committee

    When presenting his presidential agenda in the June 2019 edition of the Journal, Scott Atkins stated that diversity was one of his three priorities.
    Read More...
    Case Study

    Nine Entertainment

    Olvera principals acted as advisors to WIN Corporation in the restructure of Nine Entertainment and proposed acquisition of the business as part of a debt for equity swap.

    Olvera principals worked with Mezzanine lenders and their advisors, and distressed investors who acquired positions through a syndicate sell down.
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Hospitality & Media

    Australia is going through a food renaissance with the number of new restaurants continuing to grow at 4.7% per annum to 29,645 in 2023
    See Hospitality & Media
    Key Insight
    lettuce labour and leases

    Lettuce, labour and leases

    Over the past few months, lettuce prices have been skyrocketing, with social media users posting pictures and memes of iceberg lettuces ranging from $10 to $12

    Read More...
    Recent News
    The Restaurant Renaissance

    The Restaurant Renaissance

    Even before the coronavirus, hospitality was a sector in crisis. Skyrocketing rents, fierce competition, and stagnant prices had reduced already tight margins to the barest of slivers

    Read More...
    Case Study

    Keystone Group

    Olvera principals were appointed as Voluntary Administrators of the Keystone group.

    The Group comprised 42 Companies and numerous unit trust and discretionary trust structures which operated 17 hospitality venues nationally. Keystone had over 1200 staff and creditors claims in the liquidation totalled over $85mill.

    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Construction & Property

    The construction industry is often the budgie in the coal mine for the broader economy due to the longer-term nature of construction and development projects.

    See Construction & Property
    Key Insight
    5 signs

    5 signs your business needs restructuring

    The decision to restructure your business is not an easy one to make. The “wait and see” approach seems dangerous if you’re already facing financial pressures

    Read More...
    Recent News
    Decarbonisation

    'Decarbonisation’ key for Australian resources sector over long-term

    Australia’s resources and mining sector must radically reduce its carbon footprint as a critical corporate priority if it wants to secure its long-term future.
    Read More...
    Case Study

    Hedley Construction

    Tom Hedley sold his Hedley Hotel Group to Coles Myer in 2006 for $328 million.

    The Queensland portfolio counted 35 hotels, 102 retail liquor outlets, and sites for a further 17 botteshops, significantly boosting Coles’ expansion.
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Energy & Resources

    Australia is a commodity driven economy. Chinese dependence on Australian iron ore has supported our balance of payments, but there are significant changes which will change that balance.
    See Energy & Resources
    Key Insight
    Farewell to the Cinema

    Farewell to the Cinema?

    You have to feel sorry for the cinema. Having survived the arrival of cable, VHS, DVD, digital piracy, and the streaming revolution, it could instead be a once-in-a-century pandemic

    Read More...
    Recent News
    Trash Treasure

    Trash & Treasure

    When it comes to distressed companies I believe it is more “one man’s meat is another man’s poison” than “one man’s trash is another man’s treasure”.
    Read More...
    Case Study

    Kimberly Diamonds

    Olvera principals were appointed as Voluntary Administrators and subsequently Liquidators of a Mining Company (formerly ASX listed)

    with operations/investments across multiple jurisdictions including Africa, UK, Europe and North America. Olvera Advisors sought to extract value for stakeholders from the assets of the Company. Olvera Advisors have undertaken a:
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Financial Services

    Australia’s four pillar bank network has provided incredible stability for the Australian economy, while the economic boom and low interest rates over the past 10 years has led to more competition and the rise of non-bank lenders.

    See Financial Services
    Key Insight
    Resolving board room challenges and the issues of Independence governance

    Resolving board room challenges and the issues of Independence & governance

    At the outset I will indicate my bias in favor of controlling shareholders, in my view, their interests are aligned with the long term objectives of the company

    Read More...
    Recent News
    Untitled design 4

    Forging New Frontiers: Olvera Advisors Leads the Way in Restructuring and Insolvency

    We have an amazing announcement to make that puts Olvera Advisors at the forefront of Australia’s restructuring and insolvency industry.

    Read More...
    Case Study

    Octaviar Group

    Olvera principals were appointed as Liquidators to 14 companies in the Octaviar Group.

    The group consisted of 100 companies. The Group operated a vast array of businesses that ranged from property funds, corporate finance lending, child care centres, aged care facilities, funds management,
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Transport & Manufacturing

    In the manufacturing space the delay in obtaining and cost of transport motivated the development of more on shore production with critical customers moving to local manufacture.
    See Transport & Manufacturing
    Key Insight
    Resolving board room challenges and the issues of Independence governance

    Resolving board room challenges and the issues of Independence & governance

    At the outset I will indicate my bias in favor of controlling shareholders, in my view, their interests are aligned with the long term objectives of the company
    Read More...
    Recent News
    Global Shipping During The Pandemic

    Global Shipping During The Pandemic

    As millions of companies worldwide continue to grapple with COVID-19 it’s clear that the impact of the virus will continue to be felt for a long time after the acute phase has run its course.
    Read More...
    Case Study

    North West Crane Hire

    Olvera principals were appointed liquidators of North West Crane Hire Pty Ltd

    which operated a mining plant & equipment crane hire business based in Mt Isa, Queensland. Olvera principals undertook a recovery and realisation strategy of all the mining equipment.
    Read More...
    Our Resources

    Health & Education

    If Covid has taught us one big lesson, it is that our health system was under stress and that our private insurance and Medicare system was overwhelmed with the back log of surgeries.
    See Health & Education
    Key Insight
    Why you should care about active diversity in the boardroom

    Why you should care about active diversity in the boardroom

    If the most recent Federal election has taught us anything, it is that the make up of our Corporate Boardrooms falls far short of the level of gender diversity that our community now demands
    Read More...
    Recent News
    Untitled design 4

    Forging New Frontiers: Olvera Advisors Leads the Way in Restructuring and Insolvency

    We have an amazing announcement to make that puts Olvera Advisors at the forefront of Australia’s restructuring and insolvency industry.
    Read More...
    Case Study

    Childcare Operations

    Olvera principals were engaged by the secured creditor of a group of eight centres

    to review the corporate structure and provide recommendations for performance improvement to the working capital management. Olvera Advisors undertook:
    Read More...
    Our Resources
    Facebook Instagram Linkedin
  • Team
  • Careers
  • Resources
Contact

HOME – Insights

A Practical Guide To Voluntary Administration Process For Creditors

  • 18 August 2020
15 1

Insolvency in Business

The next two years will represent one of the most challenging times for Australian businesses.  We need to consider a different approach to dealing with customer insolvency in a way that preserves or grows our own business.

In short, it costs five times more to acquire a new customer than to retain a current customer, so why when a customer gets into financial difficulty, do we move to write them off immediately?

While insolvency might be inevitable for many businesses, the outcome is not, and the collapse of one business often causes the collapse of two or more of its suppliers.

Unfortunately, most insolvency advice is designed for directors on how to use business turnaround services, not for creditors on how to get the best outcome, and if creditors can maximise their own outcomes, then the domino effect of business failure ends.

The problem is that the majority of trade creditors act as passive participants, the voluntary administration process is confusing, and they rely on the Administrators Report, which is historical and only provides a return at a fixed point in time.

So here are the five things we tell creditors, as a business advisor:

  1. Take the emotion out of the process, be angry, that is fine, but understand that only 1 in 10 failures are the result of fraud, the other 9 are poor management decisions.  We all make poor management decisions at some point.
  2. Work out the cost of the loss, not the profit but the hard costs and labour, and compare it to what you have made in the last 12 months off the same customer – put the loss in context.
  3. At the first meeting of creditors, read the attendance register.  The attendance register lists the creditors by amount, and at the meeting talk to as many of them as possible.  Just ten creditors working together can negotiate a better deal or block a bad one.
  4. At the first meeting encourage the directors to put forward a deed proposal, you don’t have to accept it, but it sends a message to the Voluntary Administrator and the directors, that you support a restructure if the benefits of it drive your future growth – focus on the opportunity, not the loss.
  5. Talk to the directors about on-going supply arrangements, negotiate better rates, and larger order values if the deed proposal is accepted.  Look to the future.

But in order to make an informed decision, creditors need to be able to understand what they are being told, and what they are not being told in the Voluntary Administrator’s Report.

So here is what we say about reading an Administrator’s report:

  1. Ignore the recommendation – at least at first and go to the tables in the annexures and look for the table showing the return to creditors.  This table tells you where the realisations will come from and what the total creditor claims are and the expected dividend under company liquidation and the offer. Average returns in liquidations are often less than 10%.
  2. Be mindful of dividends driven by litigation – If the liquidation value is largely made up of realisations from litigation, then creditors should beware. The average time to complete litigation once an action is commenced is 18 months – 2 years, and depending on the value the minimum legal costs will be at least 25% of the value of the claims.  At the end of the day, there is no certainty that the claim will be successful.  Litigation claims also need to be funded, and if there are no assets in the company, then this will be either creditors or a litigation funder which will further reduce the recovery, as both will ask and are entitled to claim a higher return or a fee often 40% of the net recovery.
  3. Vote against preference recoveries – Look at the value attributed to preference recoveries.  Preference recoveries are monies paid to creditors in the six months prior to the appointment of the Administrator and which may be recovered by a Liquidator.  The basis of preference recoveries is to even the recoveries between creditors, but ultimately pay the Liquidators fees.  Administrator Reports don’t disclose who received the alleged preference, but this may result in the dividend in a liquidation being derived from monies being recovered from creditors.  Creditors who have received preferences should always vote against liquidation.
  4. You are always better off with the customer you know – If the Administrator is contemplating selling the business, what does this mean for creditors with respect to on-going supply agreements and future orders.  If the purchaser is to a competitor, then the future value will be limited. In this respect, we think that Administrators should always seek approval or advise creditors of an intended sale before the second meeting.
  5. Dividends in liquidation have no future value – The Administrators Report is a point in time return, it does not take into account the benefits to individual creditors or the future value of the on-going business, or the time value of the distribution. 

Creditors should always vote in their interests, but they should see insolvency as a way to understand their customers better, improve their profitability, and grow their sales.

There is no better certainty that a company is solvent than one that has had its debts settled through a deed of company arrangement and a moratorium.

If you’re a creditor of a business that requires voluntary administration services, contact us today for an obligation-free consultation with one of our specialists.

Read next: Olvera’s 5 tips to building business resilience

MORE ARTICLES

Loading...
consumer services
November 1, 2023

Insolvency & Restructuring in the Consumer Services Industry in 2024

Read More...
Capture4 1 1
April 30, 2023

Lettuce, labour and leases

Read More...
Untitled design 7 1
November 9, 2022

Why you should care about active diversity in the boardroom

Read More...
1 2 … 8

Subscribe to receive our research updates

Subscribe to receive market research, insolvency news and insights specific to you. Learn from our industry leaders and stay up-to-date with Australia’s dynamic insolvency sector.

Subscribe

Navigate change and develop on-demand skills

Your turnaround journey starts with Olvera.
Search Olvera Careers
Olvera First Logo BGY 1 2
Olvera Capital White 1

Menu

  • Home
  • Resources
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Our Team

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies

Contact

  • Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
  • Phone: +61 2 8880 4070
  • Level 6, 9 Barrack Street, Sydney NSW 2000
Facebook Instagram Linkedin Youtube

©2023 Olvera Advisors | All rights reserved

Facebook Instagram Linkedin Youtube